| Deal value | $71M |
|---|---|
| Share of market cap | 5.3% |
| Share of annual revenue | 20.7% |
Key highlights
- Total consideration of $70.7 million based on an 80% stock and 20% cash structure
- Evergreen shareholders to receive 0.4081 FMBH shares and $5.20 cash per share
- Acquisition adds approximately $932 million in total assets to the First Mid portfolio
- Transaction projected to be 5.0% accretive to earnings per share by 2028
- Closing expected in Q1 2027 subject to regulatory and shareholder approvals
What Is the Deal?
First Mid Bancshares (NASDAQ: FMBH) has reached a definitive agreement to acquire Evergreen Bancshares, Inc., the Missouri-based parent company of American Bank of Freedom. The transaction, valued at approximately $70.7 million based on recent market pricing, involves Evergreen merging into a First Mid subsidiary. Upon completion, Evergreen’s banking operations will be integrated into First Mid Bank & Trust. The deal is slated for completion in the first quarter of 2027, provided it receives the necessary approvals from federal regulators and Evergreen shareholders. This move signifies a major geographic push for First Mid into several key Midwestern hubs.
Deal Structure & Terms
The acquisition is structured as a mix of roughly 80% equity and 20% cash. Evergreen shareholders are entitled to receive 0.4081 shares of First Mid common stock along with a cash payment of $5.20 for every share of Evergreen they hold. In total, First Mid expects to issue approximately 1.1 million new shares and distribute $14.1 million in cash. The agreement includes a protective price mechanism: if Evergreen’s adjusted net worth falls below $69.3 million at the time of closing, the consideration will be reduced dollar-for-dollar, beginning with the cash portion of the payout to maintain the deal's financial integrity.
Strategic Rationale
A central objective of the merger is to scale First Mid's organization beyond the $10 billion asset milestone. Management has highlighted that recent investments in operating infrastructure, risk management, and technology were specifically designed to support this growth level. The company believes the synergies and earnings generated from this transaction will more than compensate for the increased regulatory costs associated with crossing the $10 billion asset threshold. Strategically, the acquisition fills regional gaps along the I-70 corridor, establishes a full-service presence in Indianapolis, and strengthens the existing Illinois franchise through the Rochester market.
Business Overview
- Headquartered in Wellsville, Missouri, with historical operations dating back to 1880
- Operates 10 banking centers across the St. Louis metro area, Illinois, and Indiana
- Maintains a specialized loan production office serving the Denver, Colorado market
- Reported total consolidated assets of $932 million as of late September 2026
- Manages a loan portfolio of $712 million and total deposits of $727 million
Financial Context
With a current market capitalization of $1.34 billion, First Mid is utilizing this acquisition to drive significant long-term value. The deal is expected to be 5.0% accretive to earnings per share in 2028, reflecting fully phased-in cost savings estimated at 33% of Evergreen's noninterest expenses. Despite the acquisition's scale, tangible book value dilution is expected to be minimal at 0.5%, with a rapid earnback period of just six months. First Mid intends to maintain a robust capital position post-merger, targeting a pro forma Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 13.6%.
Up 0.4% since our story on 29 Oct: $50.52 when we broke it → $50.70 at the close on 16 Nov. Daily closing prices. Source: Yahoo Finance.
Show the prices
| 19 Oct | $49.07 |
|---|---|
| 20 Oct | $49.88 |
| 21 Oct | $49.26 |
| 22 Oct | $50.62 |
| 23 Oct | $50.74 |
| 26 Oct | $51.11 |
| 27 Oct | $51.01 |
| 28 Oct | $50.52 |
| 29 Oct | $51.13 |
| 30 Oct | $50.40 |
| 2 Nov | $51.47 |
| 3 Nov | $50.84 |
| 4 Nov | $51.94 |
| 5 Nov | $50.86 |
| 6 Nov | $50.61 |
| 9 Nov | $51.50 |
| 10 Nov | $51.24 |
| 11 Nov | $51.29 |
| 12 Nov | $51.19 |
| 13 Nov | $51.32 |
| 16 Nov | $50.70 |
| Date | Announcement | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| 02 Feb 2026 | Acquisition of Downs Insurance Agency, Inc.Source: firstmid.q4ir.com | $1.4 Million |
| 30 Oct 2025 | Acquisition of Two Rivers Financial Group, Inc.Source: firstmid.q4ir.com | $94.1 Million |
| 21 Oct 2025 | Acquisition of Ray Farm Management Services, Inc.Source: firstmid.q4ir.com | $0.8 Million |
| 01 Jul 2025 | Acquisition of select assets and customer list of AAdvantage Insurance Group LLCSource: firstmid.q4ir.com | $2.8 Million |
Management commentary
“This is also an important step for First Mid as we continue to build scale and prepare our organization for growth above $10 billion in assets. We have made significant investments in our people, technology, risk management and operating infrastructure, and we believe the additional earnings and synergies from this transaction more than offset the incremental financial impact of operating above the $10 billion threshold while positively positioning First Mid for future opportunities.”
| Share price | $50.52 |
|---|---|
| Market cap | $1.3B |
| Revenue (annual) | $342M |
| P/E (TTM) | 12.5× |
| 1-month price change | +2.29% |
| Sector | Financial ServicesBanks - Regional |
Reference market data from a third-party provider, as of the story. Not a valuation or a recommendation.
SEC filing by First Mid Bancshares, Inc. announcing the execution of a definitive merger agreement to acquire Evergreen Bancshares, Inc.
Track FIRST MID BANCSHARES, INC. live
Get the next FIRST MID BANCSHARES, INC. SEC filing seconds after it lands.



